school

UM E-Theses Collection (澳門大學電子學位論文庫)

Title

Framing Article 23 : contrasts in narratives of the Wen Wei Po, Apple Daily, Macao Daily News and People's Daily (2000-2009)

English Abstract

The legislation to implement Article 23 of the Basic Law, which concerns the prohibition of crimes against national security, was among the most controversial issues since the reunification of HKSAR and MSAR with the PRC. Reporting styles varied and media coverage was detected with great differences. This study analyzed journalistic narratives of four newspapers - Wen Wei Po and Apple Daily from Hong Kong, Macao Daily News from Macao, and People's Daily from China and examined how these newspapers had framed Article 23 differently. A total of 231 news articles from 2000 to 2009 were content analyzed. Results showed that Wen Wei Po, Macao Daily News and People's Daily reported Article 23 by the SARs' Duty Frame, Nationalism Frame and Procedural Frame while Apple Daily by Suppression of Freedom of Speech Frame, Individualism Frame and Debates Frame most common. Meanwhile, Macao Daily News was shown to be a more pro-China newspaper than the Wen Wei Po on the issue over Article 23; People's Daily, the mouthpiece of the PRC, did not totally framed Article 23 the most obvious among the three pro-China newspapers as hypothesized. Furthermore, these four newspapers framed Article 23 relatively constant within these nine years; and the four newspapers simultaneously framed Article 23 most obvious when Macao's legislation took turns.

Issue date

2010.

Author

Choi, Sin Kuan

Faculty
Faculty of Social Sciences (former name: Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities)
Department
Department of Communication
Degree

M.A.

Subject

Constitutional law -- Macau

Constitutional law -- Hong Kong

National security -- Law and legislation -- Macau

National security -- Law and legislation -- Hong Kong

Subversive activities -- Law and legislation -- Macau

Subversive activities -- Law and legislation -- Hong Kong

Journalism -- Political aspects -- China

Journalism -- Political aspects -- Macau

Journalism -- Political aspects -- Hong Kong

Supervisor

Chen, Huai Lin

Files In This Item

View the Table of Contents

View the Abstract

Location
1/F Zone C
Library URL
991005324669706306